Case Studies

Explore how HPM Consultants brings clarity to complex scheduling,delay and damages disputes.

Valley Township Muncipal Building

The Challenge

HPM Consultants was retained by the contractor of a municipal building to evaluate alleged project delays associated with construction activities. The analysis focused on determining whether soil remediation delayed project completion or whether other contractor-related events were responsible for the extended completion date.

The project involved multiple concurrent construction and tenant-improvement activities that experienced numerous schedule revisions, redesigns, and added work scopes. Soil remediation impacted completion, prompting an independent forensic schedule review by HPM Consultants.

Our Services

HPM Consultants conducted a forensic schedule analysis and comprehensive review of project documents, schedules, and weekly status reports. The evaluation examined critical-path impacts, delay-event timing, contractor coordination issues, and the effect of project modifications on overall completion.

The investigation identified significant delays related to staircase redesigns, MEP modifications, PEMB wall panel revisions, and tenant-improvement changes. HPM Consultants also performed a but-for critical path analysis to determine whether the project completion date would have changed without the soil remediation activities.

Outcome

HPM Consultants conducted a comprehensive forensic schedule analysis and but-for critical path evaluation to determine the true drivers of project delay. The but-for analysis demonstrated that removal of the disputed event from the schedule did not alter the project completion date, establishing that other project events controlled the critical path throughout the relevant period. The findings provided a clear, fact-based conclusion supported by contemporaneous project records and accepted forensic scheduling methodologies, offering the client and counsel a defensible evidentiary foundation for the dispute resolution process.

NEWS

recent from Our Blog

Expert credibility matters most once a case proceeds

Choosing the right expert can shape the outcome of a construction dispute long before a case ever reaches trial. Attorneys evaluating a construction expert witness typically look well beyond a resume, weighing technical knowledge, communication skills, and courtroom presence together. Construction scheduling experts in San Diego who check every one of these boxes can make the difference […]

Expert analysis behind construction disputes

Construction projects rarely follow a perfect timeline. Unexpected weather, design changes, labor shortages, material delays, and coordination issues can all affect progress. When these setbacks lead to financial losses, determining who is responsible and how much compensation is owed becomes a complex process. This is where proper evaluation of delay damages plays a critical role. […]